12/06/07

Food not recommended at all.

by janiceromano

My husband (a lover of pizza) and I went on a Wednesday night, for the first time there, which happens to be nickel beer night. Neither of us enjoy beer, but that is not why we will not return. The staff and atmosphere was very pleasant, but the food, we will not recommend - ever. We had placed a to go order, and waited in the restaraunt, past the alloted time they had given. It seemed, they had forgotten to call out the name, for the pick up order, even though we were right in front of them. When we finally got the food, the pizza was cold, and practically tastless, not to mention, overpriced, for the amount of food. I do have to say, the waffle fries, were good, but not very plentiful. Perhaps, if we had gone, on a night, when beer was not the priority, we would not have been overlooked, and the pizza would have been hot. But, it seems to me, the only way the food could taste good, was if a lot of alcohol, had been consumed, first. Please know, that I am not one, to complain, normally, but this time, I feel I must, especially seeing that there are good reviews, here. And, usually, I am one, to believe in second chances, but this time, I know, I will not ever, try the food again.

• Pros: atmosphere
• Cons: food

03/10/09

Friendly staff, great food!

by dznypeta

We recently discovered the American Pie Pizza Company and we LOVE it. We literally drive 30 minutes just to go three, bypassing several other pizza joints along the way. The staff is friendly and easy going. The pizza is amazing. I read some of the other reviews and cannot understand the comments on portions. The pizzas are very well portioned and the fries were so big, we couldn't finish them! If you're looking for a good pizza, good service, and a nice clean place to eat, give it a try! It doesn't hurt to go on nickel beer night on Wednesdays, either! Enjoy!

• Pros: Friendly service, good pizza, good prices!
• Cons: Just that it's so far away from us.

09/23/08

Worst Pizza Ever!!

by WeaverDr

If you want on a Tuesday night to have a pizza delivered more than an hour later from a place that's barely 3 miles away from your home, by a guy who calls you twice because he can't find your address and once he gets there does not have a pen for you to sign the credit card slip, and if you want, at the end, get not only a cold pizza, but the worst pizza ever, you definitively have to order it from these place!!

• Pros: None
• Cons: Everything

07/07/07

This is the best pizza restaurant we have ever gone to.

by cookie3985

My experiences at American Pie have been fantastic. We are repeat customers and we are remembered each time. The atmosphere is wonderful and we are treated very well. Even though we are retired we are not treated differently by the young people that work there. The owners are very good and care a great deal that their customers are treated right, but also that their employees are happy and doing a good job. The food has been great. No matter what we order it is always great.

• Pros: Very good food everytime. Very family and couple friendly.

07/06/07

Great pizza

by kayanna00

My mom was visiting from up North over 4th of July and we decided to check this place out for the first time. I haven't really found a good pizza place that I've liked in Central Florida - until now! The food tasted like real Chicago pizza and I haven't had that much fun at a restaurant in a long time. My mom especially liked the pictures of famous singers hanging from the walls!

07/05/07

Great atmosphere and awesome pizza!

by trina6277

I went here for the first time the other day with my boyfriend and we absolutely loved it. It was such a great time and there is no other restaurant like it. The food is great and it is a lot of fun.

Editorial Review

by Contributor

A dining experience bringing tasty treats and fun games all under one roof.

06/27/07

Best food and services

by abennett613

I went with a group of friends that were on vacation and they loved it! There is no restuarant like this from where they live. The music and artwork made the dining more enjoyable.

• Pros: Ambience, Services

06/27/07

Best NY style pizza in Central florida combined with entertainment for the family

by randerau

We love dining at the Oviedo location of American Pie Pizza, becuase of it's great tasting food and my kids love the music videos combined with the Play Stations at each table. Finally, there is a restaurant that is entertaining and has an exceptional food quality that makes it a great place to dine.. We like how the staff are always willing to go the extra step to make our experience more enjoyable. The show in the kitchen can also keep us entertained as we watch our pizza's being made right in front of us.. I recommend this place for all who enjoy a great N.Y style pizza and italian food at a reasonable price..

• Pros: Food Flavorfull, Ambience is very entertaining for the family
• Cons: Seating can be limited on a Friday night