Umatilla >
Nicky D's Pizza439 Umatilla Blvd, Umatilla, FL | Directions 32784
28.931533 -81.667643 View WebsiteBack To Original Owners THANK GOD!!!!!!. Thank God the original owners are back at Nicky D's. The New Owners were way overpriced terrible managers and treated customers like garbage. And a sicilian pizza is not round its square and how can a polish lady really be that great of a italian cook. Go to Nickys D's and taste what italian food should taste like.
Best Calzones and Pizza in Lake County, huge menu, Chef will make you anything you want!.
Nicky D's...A diamond in the rough. This Pizzeria has been a fixture in Umatilla for the past 6 years offering consistently tasty pizza and entrees. Well, the restaurant just recently changed hands and customers just can't say enough about the new Owners. The pizza is now superb. They use a Sicilian Chile sauce on the already amazing homemade dough. It's tough to find a pizzeria not using frozen dough and frozen meatballs (IE Anthony's, Tony's, etc). If you're Italian, a New Yorker, a Garlic lover, A Bostonian, or a Pizza expert. You have to try this place.
Not many Chefs will deviate from the menu and make you anything you want anyday of the week. As a Chef I have high expectations when visiting restaurants. I have frequented all of the other pizzerias in the area and have actually overheard people taking about the food at Nicky D's and their sister store Pizzeria Corleone while they were eating at other places.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.
