Boardwalk Pizza

stacey d.

Joined 6 months ago

Want a New York style pizza, this is the place to get it! My families favorite place to go when going out to eat, even after 15 years.

Kris R.

Joined 8 months ago

Whether dine in or take out, I know I'll always enjoy my meal at Boardwalk. I especially like the baked ziti!

Recommends

Danielle G.

Joined 1 year ago

Gluten Free Pizza!!!!. Today was my first experience with Boardwalk Pizza, and I must say it was a very pleasant experience! The girl who was running the register was very friendly and knowledgeable on their products. This is the only local pizzeria that has gluten free pizza and it tastes AMAZING! It is the closest thing to "real" pizza. I am excited to taste more of their expanding gluten free menu.

Recommends

tootie32714

Joined 6 years ago

Yum Scrum!. My husband and I have been coming here for a long time and we look forward to it every time. We have tried other local pizza places and we always compare them to Boardwalk and none of them even come close. Staff is great and friendly.

Recommends

JGeils23

Joined 2 years ago

Been a Customer for 5 years. My husband started going there when we first started dating in 2005. It was our Thursday Night place to be. He has been going there for Take Out since he was in elementary school.

As the years went on, we still went on Thursday and our Date Nights have now turned into FAMILY PIZZA NIGHT. We attend every Thursday, the staff knows all of us by name and we do not need to place an order.

People who are regulars know that this is the BEST Pizza place around the Winter Park area. Every restaurants have bad days, but that has never ever stopped us from going, cause the next week is back to normal.

Prices ARE fair and the staff are all wonderful. Even the guys in the back that you never see!!

I highly recommend going to Boardwalk Pizza if ever in the area! You will NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!!

Thank you Matt, Melissa and the rest of the staff!

Doesn't Recommend

GaryWP

Joined 2 years ago

Don't Waste Your Time or Money.... The food is average, but the prices are above average, along with the attitude of the servers. Don't waste your time or your money on these losers. Any fast food chain would be an improvement.

Doesn't Recommend

ztner

Joined 2 years ago

SLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!. I decided to stop by boardwalk for the first time after getting through with Pinch A Penny. It always seems to have people there when I get my pool supplies. I wasn't terribly hungry so I decided to get one slice. They had two pizzas on display already cooked for people whom only wanted a slice so I ordered the cheese pizza on the bottom rack with a pepsi. They told me to sit and they would bring it out. They had a modest amount of for-pick-ups (3-4) and probably 3 or 4 tables inside occupied so I sat outside. My pepsi came fast. After about 30 minutes I decided my weekend was too valuable to wait any longer for a precooked slice of pizza so I went in to the counter and told the cashier nicely that I was canceling my order and asked how much a pepsi cost and brought out three ones. She ignored me so I asked again how much a pepsi was. Still no answer and no look so I stepped back and looked at the menu. It was like 1.70 or something so I put my cup on the counter with three ones and walked out. I did mention in a normal voice that I wouldn't be back with a slight sarcasm in my tone. I think they’re approach must have been to do all orders in order, but my order was already cooked. It could have been brought out with my drink. I went down the street to Tuscany pizza and got two large slices and a pepsi to go in about 5 minutes for about $5.00. Boardwalk is definitely not dine in friendly. This is the only review I have ever made online of a restaurant.

Recommends

Sandra Carr

Joined 5 years ago

Citysearch Editorial Review. Take a bite out of authentic New York-style pizza at this Italian restaurant in Winter Park’s Lake Howell Plaza. Pizza may rule the menu but other delights entice families’ and locals’ palates, too. Calzones, ziti, lasagna, ravioli and huge subs also keep customers coming back for more. The cozy eatery’s dining room has dark red-vinyl booths and tables and is surrounded by a mural of Atlantic City’s Boardwalk, complete with beach scenes and painted windows as if viewing the famous landmark first-hand.

Recommends

bumblbee23

Joined 7 years ago

Great Pizza on the south side of the Tracks! (close to NJ). I have been going to Boardwalk for the past 20months on every Thursday. My finace introduced me to it and it became out special date night. We felt like "Norm" from Cheers when we walked in. We didnt did menus as our same waitress knew exactly what we wanted. It was great and always great food!! Definitely a place that I would recommend. Unfortunately, they have lost their head manager of the floor and the service has completely gone down hill. Hopefully the same quality of customer knowledge and great waitressing skills can be found again with the the current staff.. THAT IS THE ONLY DOWN FALL.

Great place for kids, families, dates and for the best pizza!!!

Recommends

kadibaby

Joined 7 years ago

boardwalk pizza. if you actually come from n.j. and have had alot of pizza made on the boardwalks, including atlantic city, tou'll find that this is very very close. it is not the real thing and i have been searching for 15 years to find the real thing. this is the closest ive come to it